God’s Pick in the Election

Is it Hillary? Rudy? Barack? Mitt? More importantly, has he chosen your friend or your neighbor, your wife, your parents or your children? Has he even chosen you?

mary and noah

Because, some Christians say, long before the universe was but a twinkle in God’s eye he decided on who he was going to be with in heaven and who he would condemn to the fiery pits of hell, for ever and ever and ever. Using scripture verses such as Ephesians 1:3-4 there is an entire theology based upon a very specific and literal interpretation of certain passages in the Bible. Although some of those passages would seem to be in opposition to others (even those attributed to Christ) there is usually no chance of chatting amicably about this over a cup of coffee. The case is closed and theological minds on both sides are made up. In fact, a persistence in opposing either particular point of view can result in the religious version of WMD (the word ‘HERETIC’) being brought out and dusted off. (I’ve come to develop quite a perverted fondness for that label, myself. )

Considering how cemented this philosophy is within the minds of its adherents you might think that it has roots growing all the way back to the teachings of Jesus. But, though some say Augustine is the father of this doctrine, most would give John Calvin the lion’s share of the credit. It is only after the Protestant Reformation, fully 1500 years after the death of Christ, that this philosophy was fully articulated and expounded.


I count as friends some who believe fervently in predestination, that God has decided long before we are ever born what our fate will be. I mean no offense when I say that, personally, I find this doctrine to be completely at odds with what I believe the Bible teaches us, particularly through Jesus. I also think it contradicts what God reveals to us through nature and the lives of others. Of course, I am hardly alone in this regard. It is almost as if the Christian faith is split right down the middle on this issue and, in spite of how important it would seem to be, there is something like a cease fire over the topic. John Wesley ( an opponent of this doctrine) is said to have said, “In essentials unity, in non-essentials liberty, in all things charity”. But wouldn’t this be considered an essential of the faith? I have heard popular preachers accused of being “abominations” (that’s a constructive word, isn’t it?) because they professed to having difficulty with the mysterious doctrine of the Trinity. Why is there no greater debate within the church over this very clear-cut Doctrine of Election?

I’ve read John MacArthur’s take on this; (as well as others) but I just don’t buy it. (And sorry, John, I think you are just a tad arrogant when you attribute any disagreement with the very man-made ‘TULIP’ formula as to being driven by pride. I think we could turn that one back on you as well.)


I’ve read that the renowned preacher Charles Spurgeon had such a problem with this that one week he would preach a Calvinist sermon and the next he would preach an Armenian one. Certainly we can do better than that. Can we open this up for discussion without offending each other? I would hope so. I admit that I have much to learn about the ‘why’s and wherefore’s‘ of the reformed church and I would like very much to be sympathetic yet I cannot see my way clear of this very thorny subject. Am I destined to never understand?

  1. #1 by Jason on October 1, 2007 - 2:36 am

    If God is infinite and God created people then God knew, even from a “free will” point of view, specific people who were condemned before he created them or anything else. He knew this long, long before he created them.

    So, if Calvinisitc election is at odds with Jesus then the question must be is Christ eternal? Is he God? If not, then there are many other discussions that need to happen first, but if so, then the second Person of the trinity took part in creating people that he knew would not accept him, in a free-wil scenario. At the very least God’s omniscience must be limited to not have him creating people who had no chance.

    The perceived effects of divine election happen in both scenarios, even if, in the Arminian formulation, it does not. God chose to create people who he knew weren’t going to “make it”. Is it worse that he does it for his specific purposes or that he cannot or will not control It or prevent it? Election cannot be avoided, unless God is not God in any Christian sense.

  2. #2 by Christian on October 1, 2007 - 1:53 pm


    To say that God allows people to choose damnation is not even remotely similar to the idea that he chose them for damnation. And unless I am way off base, I think that last clause is the distillation of a major point of Calvinism. Atheists seem to struggle with this same limited view of God, but come to vastly different conclusions.

    Statements to the effect that election is absolutely necessary because of God’s omniscience and omnipotence are oxymoronic. We are limiting God when we say that he must obey certain logical formula, especially when our knowledge of him and his realm are practically limited. We do not even know what ‘time’ or ‘eternity’ really mean, yet we use these terms as means to support this doctrine.

    I think this might be one reason God became man as Jesus. We run ’round and ’round on these treadmills, yet all we have to do is turn to Christ to see what God really meant: Love, redemption, sacrifice, forgiveness, grace and mercy. And yes repentance; a turning away from our sin and back towards God. If hardwired for salvation or damnation then repentance is meaningless.

    I heard John McArthur on the radio today. He said that Jesus did not come to save the world, only to save those who profess a literal belief in Jesus as God, Lord and Savior. But doesn’t someone need to meet Jesus, before he can say those all important words. And don’t saying those words, turning your life over to Jesus, aren’t they ‘works’ of a sort? So much for grace.

  1. 20 Doubtful Things that Many Christians Believe « SHARP IRON
1 8 9 10

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: